Heavily Unionized, Still Stagnating

By PoetCSW -
I recommend:

http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2011/03/middle-class_stagnation

While the above is primarily a short summary of other columns and blogs, it makes a great point: Western nations with a widely unionized workforce are still experiencing increases in wage disparity between the top 20 and bottom 20 percent (upper and lower classes). The middle class (usually defined as the middle 40-60 percent) is stagnating, as well.

I've written on this blog about the "Superstar Effect" and income. See:


Also:


The reality is that the marketplace is constantly changing. Technology has, for centuries, eliminated jobs and reduced the "value" of the lowest-level, least-specialized workers. Unions are not going to be able to offset the loss in value within some jobs. Quite bluntly, if there is any chance your job can be automated in any way, via software, robotics, or some other technology, your job will decline in "value" for a time.

Now, oddly enough, there is a point when the "low-value" job becomes high value. This is a reflection of supply and demand, as well as something known as the "exclusivity principle." Here's one example:

Cars used to be built primarily by hand. As a result, pieces were always slightly different. Quality was good, not great. Automation and assembly line techniques improved quality and reduced the "value" of the manual laborer in car assembly. Eventually, companies automated most of the automotive assembly process. Some companies can assemble a car with fewer than ten humans on that assembly line. (Though multiple lines and parts handling still require 1000 or more employees at the most automated car plants in the world.)

But which cars are the most expensive in the world? Cars made by the highest-paid production employees. The hand-assembled Rolls Royce and Lamborghini automobiles come to mind. Rolls Royce even employs some of the best-paid "leathersmiths" to prepare interiors.

It's a paradox: automation undercut the lower- and middle-class workers, to a point. The best of the best, however, improved their standings. The gap between the highly skilled specialist and the "average" worker widened. We see this in automotive plants, and we see this throughout the economy.

I'm not sure there is a solution, other than fewer people. I don't believe for a moment we can or will automate everything, including the repair of the machines, but we might be getting closer than anyone likes to admit. That's going to leave the lower-class at even more of a disadvantage.

Something to ponder.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The 90% Tax Rate Myth

By PoetCSW -
Image
[NOTE Augusut 8, 2017:  The marginal and effective U.S. Tax rates mentioned in this 2011 post have been supported by research conducted by Thomas Piketty (Paris School of Economics), Emmanuel Saez (UC Berkeley and NBER), and Gabriel Zucman (UC Berkeley and NBER). These economic researchers are well-respected by progressives. Data are data, though we differ on interpretations. "Income" vs. "Wealth" presents much of the challenge, as wealth accumulates but is not taxed in the United States. Distributional National Accounts:  Methods and Estimates for the United States published July 6, 2017, includes the following table: As the table shows, the effective tax rate for the top 1 percent peaked at 45 percent of income in 1944-45. Unfortunately, the overall revenue intake of the United States kept growing and the burden has been falling most on the bottom 50 percent. Tax increases on the middle and lower classes reduce potential economic growth since these individ
Read more

Call it 'Too Depressed to Blog'

By PoetCSW -
Though the contemporary Republican Party has never been libertarian enough for me or many others focused on economic issues, we at least imagined the GOP would lead a President Trump, who came into office with no governing experience and a platform that was populist and nationalist. The GOP has failed to do much practical at all. If you, like me, at least hoped Trump would be contained by party orthodoxy, the year has been nothing but disappointment after disappointment. Civil Rights: Hard to think of anything the GOP or Pres. Trump has proposed with which I agree, from gender issues to voting rights, the GOP is allowing Trump to lead on these subjects — in the wrong direction. Gay marriage should never have been a national issue. Private matters are private, between consenting adults. The libertarians and social conservatives will always be in conflict on these issues. On voting rights, I am okay with a basic national ID standard, as is being implemented for the TSA via ne
Read more

Krugman Misleads Again with 'Moochers Against Welfare'

By PoetCSW -
Paul Krugman, unfortunately, is the dominant voice among left-leaning economists. His columns are too often a sad example of what passes for great intellectual insight from the Coastal Elites in today's United States. Consider this series of logical leaps: Moochers Against Welfare   By PAUL KRUGMAN Published: February 16, 2012  [The] regions in which government programs account for the largest share of personal income — are precisely the regions electing those severe conservatives. Wasn't Red America supposed to be the land of traditional values, where people don't eat Thai food and don't rely on handouts? Krugman is a master of misleading arguments, resorting to a mix of straw man arguments and ad hominem insults that are meant to belittle conservative voters. Why the use of the word "moochers" for people on aid? If the goal is to make a point that people on aid are not  moochers, Krugman fails. Instead, his use comes across as insulting. A moocher
Read more